Shop Candy
  • Salt Water Taffy

    Salt Water Taffy

  • Cinnamon Bears


  • Assorted Fruit Sours


  • Chocolate Sticks

  • Popular Gifts

    Popular Gifts

  • Mix & Match
  • Taffy Mixer - Mix and Match your Favorite 3 Flavors

    Taffy Mixer

  • Gift Sets and Bundles

    Gift Sets & Bundles

  • Pick Your Sticks

    Pick Your Sticks

  • Taffy Mixer

    Choose up to 3 flavors for your custom mix. 

    Please allow 1-2 additional days for order processing 


    Do you ever find yourself wanting more of a certain flavor? Do you need a mix of particular flavors or colors for a special occasion? Do you like the ability to customize your taffy order? Do you prefer vintage flavors or untraditional mixes? If the answers are yes, then the Taffy Mixer is the tool for you. 

    Sweet Candy Company offers over 30 delicious and unique flavors of taffy so why just pick one flavor? With our pick your mix tool, you can mix and match up to 3 different flavors!

    • Customizable
    • Great for crafting, gifting, candy buffets, weddings, showers, display, themes
    • Value Pack: Approximately 210 Pieces Per Mix
    • Amount: Approximately 3 Pounds Wrapped
    • Individually Wrapped Pieces


    Taffy Mixer Nutrition Information

    Could be both: Naturally and Artificially Flavored

    • Mix & Match
    • Mix & Match

    Corn Syrup, Sugar, Vegetable Oil (Sunflower Oil Or Coconut Oil), Contains 1% Or Less Of: Egg Whites, Malic Acid, Natural And Artificial Flavors, Salt, Sodium Citrate, Yellow #5, Red #40, Yellow #6, Caramel Color, Blue #2 Lake, Yellow #6 Lake, Red #40 Lake, Blue #1, Red #3, Soy Lecithin (An Emulsifier). Contains: Egg, Soy May Contain: Milk, Almond, Peanut
    Ingredients Derived From A Bioengineered Source


    • Egg
    • Soy

    May Contain:

    • Milk
    • Almond
    • Peanut
    • Certified Gluten-Free
    • Kosher: Parve
    • Keep away from chemicals and strong odors. Store between 65ºF-75ºF. Relative Humidity < 60%.

    Customer Reviews

    Based on 21 reviews
    Joy Nelson

    So Yummy and fresh!

    Margaret Y
    Love it!

    Customer service was amazing!

    Darcy Ekstrom
    Love to choose my own blend

    Great taffy as always, and I love to be able to pick the flavors I like best.

    Love it

    The taffy here is fantastic and this was a great purchase. I only ordered one kind of taffy because they were out of the one I wanted. This was a great substitute for a few dollars more.

    Brenda Price
    Sweetie Sweet's

    We love Sweet's taffy! It's nice to be able to select preferred flavors in the Taffy Mixer option. Sweet's taffy is always fresh and they truly have the best flavors. Thanks Sweet's for a great product, easy ordering, and fast delivery.